Can You Trace Him Home?

A ONE-MINUTE OFFALY MYSTERY

Where in Offaly was he from?

Two families lived near each other in Offaly. Years later, they were neighbours again in Brooklyn, New York. One of their sons became a captain in the American Civil War. Can you guess his home town?

An Irish family leaves the countryside, a sailing ship crosses the Atlantic, and New York’s waterfront appears on the far shore.
Artist’s impression of the journey from Offaly to New York.
Clue 1His uncle was his boss

When the young man became a captain in New York, the officer in charge of his regiment was his own uncle, Michael Bennett.

Clue 2Neighbours an ocean away

In the 1860 U.S. census, researchers found the Campbells and the Bennetts living beside each other in Brooklyn.

Clue 3A place you might know

Back in Offaly, an old property survey puts households with those same surnames near each other in Monasteroris. Which town does that bring to mind?

Show me who he was

Meet James Campbell from Edenderry

James grew up in the Monasteroris area and went to America as a young child. His baptism record names Elizabeth Bennett as his mother. That surname helps explain why two families kept turning up together, first in Offaly and later in Brooklyn.

James became a captain during the war. Afterwards he joined the police in New York and went on to become a captain there too.

How far from home?

Imagine leaving Offaly with what you could carry, getting to a port and then spending five or six weeks at sea. The wind could change the course and how long the crossing took.

Many westbound sailing packets took about 34–40 days. The example below shows a southerly course from Liverpool to New York, with map pins explaining stages of the crossing. It’s an illustration of a sailing route, and the soldier register may give different ports or leave them unknown. Packet crossing times · Smithsonian account of westbound sailing



Scroll to Top
AOOffaly Heroes ⌕Heroes 👤Sign In